"Contraceptive pill linked to depression"
Source: ABC Health and Wellbeing
Published: 28 Feb 2005
Category: Pharmaceutical
Rating:
(2 stars)
what they said (Hover the mouse cursor over underlined words for more info)
New research shows women taking the oral contraceptive pill are almost twice as likely to be depressed as those who do not.
The original article can be found at: http://www.abc.net.au/news/newsitems/200502/s1312627.htm
| Criteria |
Rating |
| Novelty of Treatment |
Satisfactory (?) |
| Availability of Treatment |
Satisfactory (?) |
| Treatment Options |
Not Satisfactory (?) |
| Disease Mongering |
Not Satisfactory (?) |
| Evidence |
Not Satisfactory (?) |
| Quantification of Benefits of Treatment |
Not Satisfactory (?) |
| Harms of Treatment |
Not Satisfactory (?) |
| Costs of Treatment |
Not Applicable |
| Sources of Information |
Satisfactory (?) |
| Relies on Press Release |
Not Satisfactory (?) |
what we said (Hover the mouse cursor over underlined words for more info)
This is one of three articles featuring research that points to a possible link between use of the oral contraceptive and the development of depression. Arguably it is the worst of the three. Each article appears to be based substantially on a press release from the Alfred Hospital in Melbourne. The press release describes the research as a 'pilot study' and there is no indication in it or the stories that the research has been subjected to peer review. Neither the Alfred Hospital press release nor the newspaper story describes the study methodology or the results of the research in an interpretable way. To allege a 'doubling' of the risk of depression with such a commonly used and important medication on the basis of the information presented in the press release and story is unjustified and potentially alarmist. Fortunately the story featured independent comment from the Australian Medical Association, which provides balance and warns readers not to discontinue the pill on the strenght of this information; good advice.
public forum
|