"Obesity treated in the womb"
Source: The Courier Mail
Published: 02 Apr 2012
Category: Pharmaceutical
Rating:
(2½ stars)
Keywords: metformin diabetes pregnancy
what they said (Hover the mouse cursor over underlined words for more info)
OBESE mothers are being given diabetes pills to reduce the chance of them having a fat baby. In a world first trial, 400 overweight pregnant women in the UK and Scotland will be prescribed metformin - a drug that has been used for decades to treat diabetes and is cleared for pregnancy.
The original article can be found at: http://www.couriermail.com.au/news/world/child-obesity-treated-in-the-womb/story-e6freoox-1226316286800
| Criteria |
Rating |
| Novelty of Treatment |
Satisfactory (?) |
| Availability of Treatment |
Satisfactory (?) |
| Treatment Options |
Satisfactory (?) |
| Disease Mongering |
Satisfactory (?) |
| Evidence |
Not Satisfactory (?) |
| Quantification of Benefits of Treatment |
Not Satisfactory (?) |
| Harms of Treatment |
Not Satisfactory (?) |
| Costs of Treatment |
Not Satisfactory (?) |
| Sources of Information |
Not Satisfactory (?) |
| Relies on Press Release |
Not Applicable |
what we said (Hover the mouse cursor over underlined words for more info)
This story looks at the potential use of the weight-loss pill Metformin in obese, non-diabetic pregnant women. Metformin is not standard treatment for diabetes in pregnancy in many parts of the world, including Australia and the USA. In the UK, while NICE recommends its use, the Specialist Practice Committee does not.
The brief story is very light on expert opinion and only provides a puritanical objection to making it too easy for obese mums by popping a pill. The genuine concerns not mentioned include the risks of making babies too small, and inducing lactic acidosis in small, premature or sick babies
One positive aspect of the story was the link to the NIH trial database.
And please name those nameless health experts!
public forum
There are currently no comments on this article.
|